What is actually in a tea bag

Bags are not the enemy and dust is not a scandal. What is actually inside one, why it is cut that way, and the two cases where the format genuinely costs you something.

buying

The bag is inert

Paper or mesh, and it does nothing to the flavour. What is inside it is a commercial decision, and the decision is nearly always small-particle material because that is what extracts in three minutes. The format sets the requirement and the requirement sets the cut.

Why small particles extract faster

More surface area in contact with water. That is also why they extract bitterness faster, which is why a bag left in too long goes harsh sooner than loose leaf does. Neither is a defect; both follow from the same physics.

Where it costs you

Two cases. Flowers, because milling destroys the structure you would use to judge them — whole chamomile heads are assessable and chamomile dust is not. And aromatic leaves, whose character sits in surface oil that oxidises faster once the leaf is broken.

Where it does not

Roots, barks and roasted grains are cut or roasted whatever you buy. Nobody assesses chicory by eye. Buying these loose gains you dosing control and very little else, and the honest advice is that the argument is weaker here.

The middle option

An empty fill-your-own filter bag: your material, chosen and assessed, in a format that behaves like a bag. It costs almost nothing and is the answer for anyone who wants whole flowers and a three-minute cup.

More buying guides